Chocolate Pumpkin [Peanut] Butter Print Recipe Print Recipe

I eat this by the [ XXL ] spoonful.

… every day.

and then I lick the jar clean.

You guys, it’s practically dessert. Excuse me, HEALTHY dessert and lemme just tell ya, you’re NOT going to want to share. Solution: make two and you’ll avoid any potential fights.

If not eating straight out of the, fill in the ______. [answer: mason jar], I’ll add large spoonfuls of this delicious ‘butta’ and mix it in with greek yogurt [<– fave!], oatmeal, or even pancake mix.

Did we just go back to the question of how have I not turned orange yet?

Yeah, I’m just as shocked as you are.

[Photographed by Lisa Thiele | With Style and Grace]

FYI. . .

  • NO baking/cooking required
  • Takes less that 5 minutes to make
  • Only 4 ingredients, which you probably already have in your pantry
  • It’s FREE of gluten and dairy!

Thank you Young Married Chic for introducing me to this amazing chocolate peanut butter!

Chocolate Pumpkin Peanut Butter


  • 1 cup pumpkin puree
  • 2 [or 3] tablespoons *dark chocolate peanut butter or regular creamy peanut butter
  • 1 teaspoon of cinnamon
  • Little sweetness – Powdered stevia or Agave Nectar, to taste
  • Optional – pinch of nutmeg


In a medium bowl, mix everything together until well combined.  That’s it.

Store in an airtight container and refrigerate. Mine doesn’t last more than a week because I eat it with in a few days.


*If you don’t have the dark chocolate peanut butter, GO.  GET.  IT. You won’t regret it. BUT if you need this NOW [totally understand], mix with creamy, good quality peanut butter. Add tablespoon of cocoa powder to make it chocolaty.

Be Sociable, Share!

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • Julia

    Oh.My.Stars. No jar for me, just a bowl and a spoon. YUM!!!

  • carly {carlyklock}

    Tell me where to find this phenomenon known as dark chocolate peanut butter!

    Wait. I don’t think I can handle it. Self-discipline isn’t my strong suit.

  • Emily @ Glitz Glam Granola

    Oh my gosh- this looks absolutely delicious!! I love it when I have all the ingredients at home too! I’ll be making this asap!!

  • Maria

    I want to eat the entire jar!

  • Bev Weidner

    Whaaaaaaaaaaaat? I die.

  • Kasey

    Omg, Lisa. I have to make this ASAP!!

  • Viv

    O.M.G! The girls and I can not get enough of the cinnamon butter and now, they will seriously go nuts with this! Can’t wait to try!!!

  • Averie @ Love Veggies and Yoga

    this looks crazy good!!!

    and i pinned a drink recipe of yours on my pinterest and it’s been repinned tons already. everyone wants it 🙂

  • Natalie

    Looks AMAZING. I want to eat a whole jar. Just add salted caramel and I think my mind would explode.

  • Alison @ Ingredients, Inc.

    this looks amazing! Hope you’re doing well!

  • marla

    I would eat & bake with this bliss all the time. Until I turned orange 🙂

  • Jeanee

    Looks divine! I want to try it.

    I shared it on my blog too:

  • Diane {Created by Diane}

    looks wonderful, I will have to make some ASAP!!!

  • Jamie

    This looks amazing! I just made my batch and had to force myself to shut the lid and put it in the fridge. Thanks for sharing all of your great recipes!

  • Margherita

    How do you make pumpkin puree?

  • jessica

    where can you find dark chocolate peanut butter?